5 Remakes Better Than Their Originals

We’ve all been there: that moment watching the theater previews when you realize they are releasing a remake.

via Giphy

Most of the time, I look like ^this^ when remakes come out. I have often been called a purist old-fashioned for preferring the original versions of films. Well, can you blame me when atrocities like the 2001 Planet of the Apes or the 1997 That Darn Cat tarnish our screens?

If you think I’m being harsh, watch the originals. If you still disagree…

Via Giphy

Remakes have been around since films began. Sometimes they don’t stop. There are so many versions of A Christmas CarolRomeo and Juliet, and Robin Hood that I’m loathe to list them here. Occasionally, some remakes are on par with their originals, like The Parent Trap (1961, 1998). But even I must admit that there are times when remakes are simply better. Here are five films that are a cut above their originals.

The Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (2005)

Via Giphy

I recently had a Narnia movie marathon with a friend, in which we compared the 1988 BBC miniseries to the new film franchise. While animatronic Aslan has a special place in my heart (I’m nostalgic, okay?), there is no doubt that the updated version is superior. In terms of acting, special effects, and music, it far surpasses its predecessor.

Father of the Bride (1991)

Via Giphy

While there is nothing wrong with the 1950s version, the cast of the remake created a preferable film. Why? It’s funny. Spencer Tracy can make you chuckle, but Steve Martin, Diane Keaton, and Martin Short make you laugh so hard, you cry. Or at the very least, expel your beverage from your nose.

The Mummy (1999)

the mummy
Via Giphy

Speaking of films that have been remade a gazillion times, this version of The Mummy is a great example of when filmmakers finally get it right after several tries. What was once a tired, clichéd plot became a mixture of adventure, dark comedy, and romance, with special effects to boot. It even features a fully functional female character. Go figure.

Homeward Bound: The Incredible Journey (1993)

homeward bound 2
Via Giphy

A remake of The Incredible Journey (1963), Homeward Bound is the quintessential pet flick. Where the original is dry, the remake is humorous, without compromising the seriousness of the animals’ situation. Besides, what else can pull at your heartstrings like the final scene? I dare you to watch it without getting teary-eyed. (If you don’t, you might want to check the color of your soul.)

Meet Joe Black (1998)

joe black
Via Giphy

Yeah, you didn’t know this was a remake, didja? That’s because no one remembers Death Takes a HolidayThe remake forgoes the stilted dialogue and replaces it with an updated plot, compelling characters, and Brad Pitt having a love affair with peanut butter. Win, win, win.

Cheers, you landlubbers.

The Collected Mutineer


13 thoughts

  1. I agree with every one of these. Great remakes.

    I also agree that the original Planet of the Apes (which I just recently saw) is sooooooo much better than the remake. It’s an amazing film with so many layers, all stripped out of the remake.

    1. I remember watching The Incredible Journey when I was quite young, and thinking, what happened to the voices?? Haha. The Narnia mini-series is…interesting. If you can get over the silly special effects and the sometimes poor acting, the screenplay itself is a great adaptation from the books. It’s definitely an experience to watch! I loved them as a kid, and still do.

      1. Awesome I will definatly have a look at them yeah the old incredible journey I stumbled upon when my little brother watched it I thought it was okay but the remake tugged at my heartstrings you know specially when you think shadow has died then he comes up the hill and runs to his owner 😦

Leave a Reply! (Please be advised that all comments are moderated)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s